Skip to content

TV Review: MERLIN Series 5, Episode 12 ‘The Diamond of the Day Part 1’

Written By:

Abigail Chandler
merlin-review

We’re into the home stretch here as Arthur and his army ride to Camlann to face Morgana and Mordred. But Merlin, having lost his magic to an oversized slug, can’t be there to protect him.

This was a great set-up for the finale, with only one or two niggles. The very end of the episode, with Merlin taking on the elderly Emrys form again was the main let down. I guess the writers are trying to marry the show up with the legend by presenting the old, bearded Merlin, but it’s actually to the detriment of the show. The last thing you want to do in the finale is cover the lead actor’s face with prosthetics. Also, after all this time, what we really want to see is Merlin accepting his magic without the disguise. Instead, he’s still hiding. I can only hope that the old Emrys make-up doesn’t last long in the final episode, impressive as it is.

But that ending was really the only flaw in the episode. Morgana is enjoyably mental, and Mordred seems uncomfortably aware of the fact. The sight of them combining their magic to firebomb Camelot’s garrison was suitably impressive. They’re like a medieval WMD. And those two sword fights at the end were truly the stuff of big-screen blockbusters (did anyone else cheer to see Percival leading a charge? Bless him). Merlin can often be accused of overdoing the slow-mo battles, but when it showcases all the snazzy fight moves Bradley James has picked up over the years, who cares?

The action scenes in this episode, though, are really beside the point. The heart of the episode lies in Arthur and Merlin’s relationship, and Merlin’s lost powers. The opening game of dice between the two of them was good fun and a nice last piece of levity between them before Merlin gets face-raped by Morgana’s latest magical pet and loses his magic. Colin Morgan is fantastic throughout, looking utterly bereft without his powers, a shadow of his usual quietly confident self. Merlin even seems somehow smaller, and the terror with which he screams for Gwaine to save him when he’s attacked by a bandit is shocking to both the character and the audience.

Quite why Morgana chooses to trap the powerless Merlin in the Crystal Cave rather than kill him is a bit of a mystery (hey, if it’s good enough for Bond villains, it’s good enough for Morgana), but it does lead to Merlin’s beautifully played lowest point. Luckily, his Ghost Dad is on hand for a pep talk (it’s been a good series for dead dads) and soon he’s all better and powered up, even communicating with Arthur via crystals – although if I was Gwen I’d worry about my husband waking up in the middle of the night calling out Merlin’s name…

Speaking of Arthur, the scene where Merlin tells him he won’t be coming to Camlann is of course the highlight of the episode. It’s as painful as any break-up scene, and as any good script writer knows you always want to drive a wedge between your central couple as you go into the third act.

Everything, aside from the presence of old Merlin, is perfectly in place for the finale. Merlin and Gwaine got one last mini adventure together (in between Gwaine shagging treacherous village girls – that was odd), but it did smack of a final goodbye between them. Will Gwaine survive the final battle? Mordred was last seen making his way through the battle, looking for Arthur. Gwen and Arthur got one last big romantic scene, and everything is in place for the chief relationship in the show to take centre stage – it’s always been all about the bromance.

Abigail Chandler

You May Also Like...

armando iannucci to pen script for paddington 4

Armando Iannucci Tapped To Direct PADDINGTON 4

The Thick of It and Veep creator Armando Iannucci is taking on Britain’s favourite marmalade-eating bear, with news that the Scottish comedian will be penning the script for Paddington 4.
Read More
jean grey and cyclops in the season 2 trailer for x-men '97

X-MEN ’97 Season 2 Trailer Sees Mutants Lost In Time

“The X-Men are scattered through time; In the past, from the start of Apocalypse’s reign, to the future, at the height of his rule,” so announces the X-Men ’97 season
Read More
robert de niro in angel heart

ANGEL HEART Series Adaptation To Star Zac Efron

A new adaptation of William Hjortsberg’s 1978 novel Falling Angel, which was famously turned into the Robert De Niro-starring neo-noir horror movie Angel Heart in 1987, is on the way
Read More
robert pattinson plays chris hansen in primetime film about to catch a predator

PRIMETIME Teaser Trailer Sees Robert Pattinson As Chris Hansen

Robert Pattinson loves any excuse to put on a weird voice, and his latest role is no exception: he stars in the new teaser trailer for Primetime, A24’s upcoming film
Read More

BABYLON 5 Heads to LEGEND

The cult sci-fi TV show Babylon 5 is heading back to screens as it lands on LEGEND from June 8th. The show’s synopsis is: Following a war between Earth and
Read More
stormfront in vought rising trailer

VOUGHT RISING Spinoff Series Teases First Look

The world of The Boys is rewinding to the ’50s, with Prime Video releasing a first look at their new spinoff series, Vought Rising. The series will explore the origins
Read More