Skip to content

THEY CAME TO A CITY (1944)

Written By:

Kieron Moore
they came city

Ealing Studios are best known for their post-war comedies, which gently satirised British society. But one earlier Ealing production had a much more direct political edge and a sci-fi element to boot – their adaptation of the J. B. Priestley play They Came to a City.

The city in question lies in a mysterious dream-like realm, which nine disparate Britons are suddenly transported to. The first half of the film sees them exploring the strange architecture of the city’s gatehouse, waiting for the door into the city below to open. The second half sees a conflict between these characters spark as they return from the city, having found it to be a socialist civilisation quite distinct from the class-stratified Britain they’ve come from.

So we never actually get to see this city, just hear about it through dialogue, with the entirety of the story (excluding an odd and unnecessary framing device starring Priestley as himself) taking place in this strange futurist gatehouse. While this is an impressively striking set, the static nature of the drama does rely heavily – perhaps too heavily – on the script’s theatrical origins.

Which means that the success of the film relies on its characters and dialogue. Thankfully, from a skilled playwright like Priestley, many thought-provoking themes are brought to the forefront of these interactions. It’s a story highly concerned with class; the City banker and fusty knight of the realm see the city as an uncivilised dystopia, while the working class mechanic and cleaner see it as quite the opposite, a utopia. The story also touches on issues of misogyny, with Googie Withers’ waitress Alice fed up with the way men treat her in the world she comes from.

While these issues are powerful and indeed still relevant, however, the lack of subtlety with which they come to a head in the final minutes may grate on some viewers; John Clements certainly pulls no punches with his rousing speech calling for us to make our own world a better place, but in moments like these, the film gets so preachy about its politics that it almost forgets it has a story to tell.

This new dual Blu-ray and DVD release from the BFI looks great in high definition and comes with an impressive bunch of extras. Highlights include a lecture from producer Michael Balcon about his career; a short GPO documentary about communications technology, narrated by Priestley; a 20-minute propaganda film written by Dylan Thomas; and an animated short on the new National Health Service – all clearly of their time but nonetheless fascinating to those interested in British history.

THEY CAME TO A CITY (1944) / CERT: U / DIRECTOR: BASIL DEARDEN / SCREENPLAY: J. B. PRIESTLEY, BASIL DEARDEN, SIDNEY COLE / STARRING: JOHN CLEMENTS, GOOGIE WITHERS, RAYMOND HUNTLEY / RELEASE DATE: APRIL 23RD

Kieron Moore

You May Also Like...

guests fantastic films

First Guests Announced for Festival of Fantastic Films

The wonderful Festival of Fantastic Films, which takes place in October in Manchester, has announced the first guests for the 2026 event. Appearing at the festival will be Susan Penhaligan,
Read More

Colchester Gets a Midsummer Scream from Black Sunday

Black Sunday Film Festival returns with its annual summer mini-fest Midsummer Scream on Saturday July 18th at Firstsite in Colchester. Alongside a stacked selection of feature presentations and acclaimed short
Read More
armando iannucci to pen script for paddington 4

Armando Iannucci Tapped To Direct PADDINGTON 4

The Thick of It and Veep creator Armando Iannucci is taking on Britain’s favourite marmalade-eating bear, with news that the Scottish comedian will be penning the script for Paddington 4.
Read More
jean grey and cyclops in the season 2 trailer for x-men '97

X-MEN ’97 Season 2 Trailer Sees Mutants Lost In Time

“The X-Men are scattered through time; In the past, from the start of Apocalypse’s reign, to the future, at the height of his rule,” so announces the X-Men ’97 season
Read More
robert de niro in angel heart

ANGEL HEART Series Adaptation To Star Zac Efron

A new adaptation of William Hjortsberg’s 1978 novel Falling Angel, which was famously turned into the Robert De Niro-starring neo-noir horror movie Angel Heart in 1987, is on the way
Read More
robert pattinson plays chris hansen in primetime film about to catch a predator

PRIMETIME Teaser Trailer Sees Robert Pattinson As Chris Hansen

Robert Pattinson loves any excuse to put on a weird voice, and his latest role is no exception: he stars in the new teaser trailer for Primetime, A24’s upcoming film
Read More