As the Maid of Might gets set to return for her fifth season, The CW’s Supergirl has added another villain to its ranks.

Via Variety, Lucifer’s Jennifer Cheon Garcia has signed on to play the nefarious Midnight in the Melissa Benoist-starrer. This take on the rogue is pegged as “the physical manifestation of darkness” and will be on a mission to take down the person responsible for putting them in an otherworldly prison.

Supergirl’s fifth season will premiere October 6th.