Hot off her Emmy nomination for her portrayal of Sofia Falcone in HBO’s The Penguin, Cristin Milioti has selected her next project, an independent horror thriller titled Buddy.

Casper Kelly, who co-created Adult Swim shows Your Pretty Face Is Going to Hell and Too Many Cooks, is directing the feature, as well as co-writing the script alongside Jamie King. J.D. Lifshitz and Raphael Margules are producing via their BoulderLight Pictures, the banner behind Companion, Friendship, and the upcoming horror movie Weapons. Tyler Davidson and Drew Sykes are producing for Low Spark Films, the production company that counts the Aubrey Plaza-starring Emily the Criminal and Take Shelter among its credits.

Plot details are being kept under wraps, but the project is being mysteriously described as a “new experience in horror.” Coming from Kelly, this won’t sound surprising to anyone who has watched his work — which includes a fake commercial titled “Goblin Chedder” in STARBURST’s beloved horror movie, Mandy.

Aside from the numerous accolades she’s garnered for The Penguin, Cristin Milioti counts acclaimed 2020 time-loop romantic comedy Palm Springs, opposite Andy Samberg, as well as several episodes of Black Mirror and the long-running comedy How I Met Your Mother, among her acting credits.