DVD Review: Another Earth

PrintE-mail Written by Chris Holt

Review: Another Earth / Director: Mike Cahill / Screenplay: Brit Marling, Mike Cahill / Starring: Brit Marling, William Mapother / Release Date: Out Now

Science Fiction concepts have and can be used to tell some very human stories. Recently Lars Von Trier used an end of the world scenario in his portrayal of depression in Melancholia. Inception is very much a film about grieving and moving on and Contact is about self-discovery. I think Another Earth is about accepting responsibility but it’s hard to say, the film seems too in love with its own sense of self importance and its unique idea that any message gets lost in the pretentiousness.

The film begins with promising MIT student Rhoda (Brit Marling) getting wasted one night and whilst drink driving, spotting the emergence of a new Earth-like planet in the night sky. This distraction leads to her wiping out the family of John (William Mapother) and leaving him in a coma. Four years later, Rhoda is released from jail and gets a janitor job in the local school. After the energetic opening this is where Another Earth slows right down. The planet is still there in the sky, and it’s learned that it is an exact copy of our planet, and is even populated by the same people living here. We hear about this through radio and television broadcasts. This is all just white noise however as Rhoda has started to pose as a contracted cleaner for John who mopes about in his run down shack in the countryside. Ill-advisedly Rhoda and John get close, John not knowing that this is the lady responsible for the death of his family. Around the same time a competition opens up to take part in the first manned mission to ‘Earth 2’ and Rhoda enters. You don’t need a bachelor’s degree in storytelling to see where this is headed.

There is nothing wrong with the central idea at the core of Another Earth; it’s a fascinating idea to think of another exact copy of our planet down to the last detail suddenly appearing in the galaxy. It’s an idea full of possibilities which sadly are not explored to their fullest. Director Mike Cahill is much more concerned with getting in as many slow motion shots of Brit Marling moping around in a hoodie as possible. There really isn’t much to this story, where you should be fascinated and gripped by the possibilities and where it goes, instead much of Another Earth is predictable and forced.

The film is well acted though and has some good performances that are well judged despite the floaty camera work. Cahill is good at framing a shot of one of his miserable protagonists against the background of the new planet in the sky and this seems to be his main passion. Despite lack of focus William Mapother proves again he is much more than just the cousin of the world’s biggest star and Brit Marling is fully justified in her label as the new indie 'it girl'.

I feel like this film should have justified a 1000 word long discussion on the themes and meaning inherent in the wonderful imagery that Mike Cahill gives us. Sadly Another Earth doesn’t justify this level of discussion; it barely registers and is mostly harmless. Director Mike Cahill shows promise but must work with a better script if he is ever going to become more than just another mediocre indie director.

Extras: None


Suggested Articles:
In The Perfect Insider a programming genius is murdered in a locked room in her research base. Visit
Jamil Dehlavi’s Jinnah documents the trials and tribulations of Mohammed Ali Jinnah, the man
With a tagline reading ‘Lies eventually catch up’, Malcolm Deegan’s sole feature outing as wri
The success of Easy Rider in 1969 took everyone by surprise and after it, the big studios scrambled
scroll back to top

Comments  

 
0 #2 Chris Holt 2012-04-09 12:53
I appreciate a good idea I just felt that beyond the initial set up the film has nothing to say beyond navel gazing. But hey, different strokes for different folks : )
Quote
 
 
0 #1 Ashley 2012-04-06 19:23
I really enjoyed the low key approach to the film and I found it easy to empathise with the character of Rhoda making her emotional journey a compelling and dramatically effective one.
Not a film for everyones taste I appreciate, but it resonated with me and had more to say than the majority of those empty headed Sci-Fi blockbusters.
Quote
 

Add comment

Security code
Refresh

Other articles in DVD / Blu-ray Reviews

THE PERFECT INSIDER - COMPLETE SEASON COLLECTION 03 December 2016

JINNAH (1998) 02 December 2016

FRACTIONAL 02 December 2016

THE HIRED HAND (1971) 02 December 2016

IRONSIDE SEASON 4 02 December 2016

IRONSIDE SEASON 3 02 December 2016

STAR TREK: THE RODDENBERRY VAULT 02 December 2016

GHOST IN THE NOONDAY SUN 29 November 2016

AKIRA: THE COLLECTOR’S EDITION 29 November 2016

ASTERIX: THE MANSIONS OF THE GODS 29 November 2016

- Entire Category -

Sign up today!
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner

      
      
 
...