THE PHYSICIAN

PrintE-mail Written by John Townsend

The Physician is the definition of cinematic style over substance. Hidden behind the beautiful vistas and extraordinarily detailed sets is a story so mediocre and lacking in interest that it makes you wonder why it was ever made at all.

Following the death of his mother, young boy Rob joins a Barber (Stellan Skarsgard), a kind of medieval medicine man, on his travels. Several years later, confused by a gift that allows him to sense when someone is about to die and interested in learning the true art of healing, Rob (Tom Payne) sets off to Persia to study under the legendary Ibn Sina (Ben Kingsley). Gaining access to Muslim lands by pretending to be a Jew (which involves a little homemade circumcision), Rob hones his skills battling an outbreak of the bubonic plague in the shadow of political upheaval that may eventually lead to war.

Based on Noah Gordon’s European best seller, Phillip Stolzl’s film struggles throughout with a central premise that in itself just isn’t that exciting. The story of a young man learning about healing, interwoven with numerous other narrative strands, may provide enough sustenance for an epic period novel, but when stripped down that central story feels isolated and hollow. The early part of the film suffers in particular as Rob’s story jumps around from plot point to plot point, compounded by poor editing that gives the whole thing a feeling of being no more than a hastily constructed highlights package. Performances are either hammy (Olivier Martinez as the tyrannical Shah) or wearily phoned in (Kingsley’s dreary doctor), with some character arcs never being fulfilled, presumably with key scenes left on the cutting room floor. Only astonishing camera work from cinematographer Hagen Bogdanski offers any interest, but this sadly remains purely on the surface.

The lack of any intrigue or urgency is symbolised by the film’s most “tense” scene. Never before has a third act hinged so much on an appendectomy as it does in The Physician, as Rob and his mentor struggle against the odds to perform what is portrayed as the first operation in history. While seemingly integral to the film’s themes of tolerance and acceptance, of balancing religion against emerging scientific knowledge, it feels desperately clichéd in offering justification for certain character’s actions and principles.

Suffering badly from grandiose over-ambition, The Physician never demonstrates the confidence to match its lofty intent. The astounding beauty of its design and cinematography is no match for the sheer number of its failings, and you get the sense the filmmakers hopes are to dazzle their audience with superficial charms akin to a magician’s sleight of hand. Look closely and The Physician is shallow and dull, more cinematic anaesthetic than epic adventure.

Special Features: Making of

THE PHYSICIAN / CERT: 15 / DIRECTOR: PHILIPP STOLZL / SCREENPLAY: JAN BERGER / STARRING: TOM PAYNE, STELLAN SKARSGARD, OLIVIER MARTINEZ, EMMA RIGBY, BEN KINGSLEY / RELEASE DATE: OUT NOW


 


Suggested Articles:
Jamil Dehlavi’s Jinnah documents the trials and tribulations of Mohammed Ali Jinnah, the man
With a tagline reading ‘Lies eventually catch up’, Malcolm Deegan’s sole feature outing as wri
The success of Easy Rider in 1969 took everyone by surprise and after it, the big studios scrambled
Raymond Burr's Ironside is back for more network crime solving in another 26 episodes for the fourth
scroll back to top

Add comment

Security code
Refresh

Other articles in DVD / Blu-ray Reviews

JINNAH (1998) 02 December 2016

FRACTIONAL 02 December 2016

THE HIRED HAND (1971) 02 December 2016

IRONSIDE SEASON 4 02 December 2016

IRONSIDE SEASON 3 02 December 2016

STAR TREK: THE RODDENBERRY VAULT 02 December 2016

GHOST IN THE NOONDAY SUN 29 November 2016

AKIRA: THE COLLECTOR’S EDITION 29 November 2016

ASTERIX: THE MANSIONS OF THE GODS 29 November 2016

KICKBOXER: VENGEANCE 29 November 2016

- Entire Category -

Sign up today!
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner

      
      
 
...