HARLEY QUINN VOL. 1: HOT IN THE CITY

PrintE-mail Written by Ed Fortune

COMIC REVIEW: HARLEY QUINN VOL. 1: HOT IN THE CITY / AUTHOR: JIMMY PALMIOTTI, AMANDA CONNER / ARTIST: CHAD HARDIN, STEPHANE ROUX AND GUESTS / PUBLISHER: DC / RELEASE DATE: OCTOBER 26TH

Marvel and DC are always copying ideas from each other in order to outdo each other and somehow gain the edge. It’s a fine tradition, and this time round its DC’s turn to take a leaf out of Marvel’s book. Namely, the new Harley Quinn comic, Hot in the City which bears more than a passing resemblance to Deadpool, Marvel’s anarchic and hyper-violent anti-hero whose wacky hi-jinks have kept geeks entertained for so long. The result is a book that is barely coherent and constantly breaks the fourth wall.

Harley Quinn Vol. 1: Hot in the City begins with a post-modern round robin, where Quinn wonders out loud what her own comic book would look like. Cue a series of guest artists each doing a short pastiche of their own work in an appropriately wacky style. For the bulk of the book Chad Hardin and Stephane Roux are on hand as artists and they do seem to have a lot of fun drawing Harley. The result is a pleasing mish-mash that is very easy on the eye throughout.

The story is a similar sort of mess, more of an excuse to line up Harley for the next gag or the next splash page. As a result, the plot wanders about all over the place but we do get to see some cool things such as Harley Quinn as a Roller Derby Girl. The book introduces some fun new characters as well, such an 80-year-old cyborg and wise-cracking (and dead) beaver.

All of the things you’d expect from a Harley Quinn book are here; murder, mayhem and both Harley and Poison Ivy in a series of compromising (but strictly PG-13) poses. The key problem is that Palmiotti and Conner’s script isn’t funny or clever enough to keep the reader interested for two-hundred-and-twenty-five pages.  This is a real shame because the character has a lot of potential for both pathos and humour; indeed, this is the thing that makes Deadpool so popular. Instead the creators have gone for the cheap sell; they know people will buy it simply to look at the very pretty artwork and laugh at the comedic violence. Harley Quinn Vol. 1: Hot in the City feels like it was written with a list of ‘what will sell’ in mind rather than an actual story and results in a disappointing book. If you must, buy it for the pictures, not the story.


Suggested Articles:
Fanzines have of course been around since fandom began and are a mainstay of our genre culture. Some
The legend of Sir Bevis of Hampton is a story from British medieval mythology which has somehow fall
Billed as ‘A Doctor Who Comics Event’, Supremacy of the Cybermen, a five-issue mini-series from
Julia Davenport has a problem in her sex life – whenever she orgasms, she releases a mysterious de
scroll back to top

Add comment

Security code
Refresh

Other articles in Comic Book Reviews

VWORP VWORP! VOLUME 3 26 March 2017

BLOOD AND VALOUR 20 March 2017

DOCTOR WHO – SUPREMACY OF THE CYBERMEN 17 March 2017

OFF GIRL #1 04 March 2017

WRAITHBORN VOLUME 1 27 February 2017

MY SO-CALLED SECRET IDENTITY VOL. 2 26 February 2017

THE BIG COMIC CON 24 February 2017

ROYAL DESCENT #4 14 February 2017

BATMAN 66 MEETS WONDER WOMAN 77 08 February 2017

ROBYN (ISSUE ONE) 07 February 2017

- Entire Category -

Sign up today!
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner