DOCTOR WHO: THE TENTH DOCTOR #1

PrintE-mail Written by Scott Varnham

COMIC REVIEW: DOCTOR WHO – THE TENTH DOCTOR #1 / AUTHOR: NICK ABADZIS / ARTIST: ELENA CASAGRANDE, ARIANNA FLORIAN / PUBLISHER: TITAN / RELEASE DATE: OUT NOW 

If each story in Titan's new Doctor Who comic range is equivalent to a TV episode, this first one is the 20 minutes that probably should have been left on the cutting room floor.

Consider how introducing a new companion was done in Rose. We see her waking up; going to work; meeting her boyfriend, and all of this is completed within a quick montage. The backstory comes out gradually over the course of subsequent episodes but we have basically all we need to know by the end of the first episode. This first issue of the new Tenth Doctor storyline, on the other hand, is all setup. We meet his new companion, Gabriella Gonzalez and get to know her and her extensive family in excruciating detail. So much so in fact, that it is difficult to care too much about them as you just want to see the Doctor (who in any case, doesn’t appear much in this issue).

At least he’s drawn quite well when you do see him though, which is more than we can say about 11’s character model (more on that in our review of that comic). This is true of the artwork in general, which is pretty consistently nice (apart from one or two moments that are giggle-inducing when they’re presumably supposed to be serious).

The mini-comic at the end of the issue isn’t as good as the one in the Eleventh Doctor’s comic though, especially when you consider that the other comic has two as opposed to this one. This has only a single comic which serves as little more than an advertisement for the little vinyl figures Titan are doing. This is a bit shameless but harmless enough, and at least it’s an inventive way to do it.

The problem with this comic; is that when reading it, one gets the feeling that it could have been cut down by half its length and it wouldn’t have lost much. When that’s the state of affairs, something’s gone wrong.

 


Suggested Articles:
The port town of Stonehaven in northeast Scotland has come under the scourge of bloodsucking undead.
Everyone knows Sherlock’s story, but what about his older – and apparently smarter -brother Mycr
Is the voice the seat of the soul? Sound engineer Hermann Karnau thinks so, and he’s obsessed with
Leah Moore and John Reppion’s graphic adaptations of stories by M.R. James continue in this second
scroll back to top

Add comment

Security code
Refresh

Other articles in Comic Book Reviews

VAMPIRES EVERYWHERE 14 October 2017

MYCROFT HOLMES AND THE APOCALYPSE HANDBOOK 03 October 2017

VOICES IN THE DARK 03 October 2017

ALIEN TOILET MONSTERS #1 03 October 2017

GHOST STORIES OF AN ANTIQUARY 2 02 October 2017

MOMENTS OF ADVENTURE – COLLECTION TWO 29 September 2017

THE LIZARD 29 September 2017

ATARI SWORDQUEST 29 September 2017

THE SHOWDOWN VOL. 2: THE RACE FROM HELL 28 September 2017

P M BUCHAN'S HANGOVER 28 September 2017

- Entire Category -

Sign up today!
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner