PROTECTORS INC - VOL 1

PrintE-mail Written by Ed Fortune

Protectors Inc

REVIEW: PROTECTORS INC. – VOLUME 1 / AUTHOR: J. MICHAEL STRACZYNSKI / ARTIST: GORDON PURCELL, MICHAEL ATIYEH/ PUBLISHER : IMAGE / RELEASE DATE: OUT NOW

Protectors Inc. is the latest graphic novel from J. Michael Straczynski , a writer better known for his TV series, Babylon 5. Unlike a more regular superhero world, Protectors Inc. is a place where super-powered humans are part of a larger corporate franchise. The thing that makes them powerful is seemingly attracted to the wealthy (though it’s not explained why this is) and those with powers are also celebrities. When one of these creatures dies, it’s clearly the fault of someone with similar powers and a gritty, hard-boiled Chicago Police detective has to solve the murder.

Postmodern commentary on superhero books has been done so much that it’s become its own subgenre. Protectors lacks the groundbreaking insight of Watchmen and is closer in style to Garth Ennis’ The Boys. Though it doesn’t suffer from that book's childishness and toilet humour, it doesn’t fill the void with anything either. Despite a promising start, what we get is a fairly bland detective story with incredibly unsubtle social commentary and some sharp digs at the broader comic book industry.

This isn’t even JMS’s first go at the idea; some of the characters feel like they’ve been cut and pasted from Rising Stars, the women particularly. It’s hard not to think of the detective character as Garibaldi from Babylon 5 and the plot itself also feels lifted from various parts of JMS’s previous work. This mishmash of ideas works fine and the pacing is good – it’s simply nothing terribly special and lacks the sort of spark we’ve come to expect from the author.

The art is functional and a little bland. Everyone looks the same as everyone else and the character design is a little lacklustre. It also doesn’t help that every single character looks like they’ve either just chewed a wasp or that they’re posing for a photo shoot. Both Purcell and Atiyeh are clearly capable of producing much, much better.

Protectors Inc Volume 1 is one for the hardcore fans; we can only hope that the story improves after this disappointing opening book.





Suggested Articles:
The legend of Sir Bevis of Hampton is a story from British medieval mythology which has somehow fall
Billed as ‘A Doctor Who Comics Event’, Supremacy of the Cybermen, a five-issue mini-series from
Julia Davenport has a problem in her sex life – whenever she orgasms, she releases a mysterious de
Melanie is a shy, insecure and put-upon teenager who would most likely have remained that way were i
scroll back to top

Add comment

Security code
Refresh

Other articles in Comic Book Reviews

BLOOD AND VALOUR 20 March 2017

DOCTOR WHO – SUPREMACY OF THE CYBERMEN 17 March 2017

OFF GIRL #1 04 March 2017

WRAITHBORN VOLUME 1 27 February 2017

MY SO-CALLED SECRET IDENTITY VOL. 2 26 February 2017

THE BIG COMIC CON 24 February 2017

ROYAL DESCENT #4 14 February 2017

BATMAN 66 MEETS WONDER WOMAN 77 08 February 2017

ROBYN (ISSUE ONE) 07 February 2017

BRETHREN BORN ISSUES 1 & 2 06 February 2017

- Entire Category -

Sign up today!
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner