Comic Review: STAR TREK THE NEXT GENERATION / DOCTOR WHO - ASSIMILATION2 #7

PrintE-mail Written by Paul Mount

Review: Star Trek – the Next Generation/Doctor Who – Assimilation2 #7 / Writer: Scott Tipton, David Tipton / Artist: Gordon Purcell, J.K. Woodward / Publishers: IDW Publishing / Release Date: Out Now

Inevitably, our last hopes that the Doctor Who/Next Generation comics crossover would pull the proverbial rabbit out of the hat in its last couple of issues and turn a stodgy, talky and rather dull story into something clever, exciting and, most importantly, worthy of all the hype, disappear slowly down the plughole in another issue of earnest over-talking, but with a hint of action - and some Cybermen at last! - in the final couple of pages. But in all honesty it’s just far too little, far too late.

Assimilation2 has, quite simply, run out of story. When we last saw the Doctor, he and his chums had travelled back into Star Trek: The Next Generation's timeline and they were treading carefully around a Borg Cube and gazing in awe at Captain Picard is his Locutus days. Unfortunately for anybody expecting any real action, it appears that the Doctor and co are too inconsequential to register as a threat (er...the Doctor is a Time Lord, what bigger threat could a hostile alien force expect to meet?) so they return to the TARDIS, nip back to the Enterprise, chat to Picard and co for a bit before deciding the best thing they can do is pop over to one of the Cybermen's ships and use the Borg executive code just recovered from the Borg cube to reverse the programming used to subjugate the Borg. So it's all aboard the TARDIS to the middle of the Cyber Armada where, thankfully, the Cybermen are slightly more alert than the Borg and as soon as the party step out of the TARDIS alarms are sounding and the Cybermen are on the march.

Familiar criticisms apply to #7 of Assimilation2. Despite the bit of action which perks up the last few pages and a final panel which promises some decent Cyberaction in the finale, there's still far too much talking going on, the writers still unable to resist filling the comic with panel after panel of talking heads just to show off how well they've grasped the characterisations of the TARDIS and Enterprise crews. But unfortunately we stopped being impressed by that in #3 because in reality, it was the very least we expected. We certainly hoped for a more dynamic and inventive story and not one which looks set to fizzle out next month with some pseudo-scientific mumbo jumbo which will see the Borg turn on the Cybermen again and the Doctor and co waving a cheery bye-bye to Picard and his starchy Star Trek chums. If IDW are tempted to cross-pollinate these two sci-fi giants again, they might want to take a bit more time to come up with a story which makes the writing, drawing and reading of it worth the effort, because this just has the stink of a lazy vanity project about it, and fans of both franchises were undoubtedly expecting and deserving quite a bit more.


Suggested Articles:
In this penultimate issue of the relentlessly bleak horror series, dead serial killer Matt reaches t
After spending years navigating a world drowned by rising sea levels, drifting sailor Charlie though
2000AD has always had an interesting approach to comedy. The world famous anthology comic rarely rea
Showtime is the story of a magician told by a journalist and relayed by a rodent. Not only is the co
scroll back to top

Comments  

 
0 #1 Raphael Edwards 2012-12-02 10:05
I have to disagree with the continual negative reviews of this series. Having purchased the first combined volume, I thought it was original, refreshing and exciting. Great use of style change for the Kirk/Baker era too, was inspired. You clearly don't like the series Paul, so maybe a fresh set of eyes should be reviewing the rest.
Quote
 

Add comment

Security code
Refresh

Other articles in Comic Book Reviews

CITY OF LOST SOULS #5 21 September 2017

BOAT VOLUME 3: BLOOD IN THE WATER 20 September 2017

SURVIVAL GEEKS 12 September 2017

SHOWTIME 12 September 2017

BATMAN: THE DARK KNIGHT: THE MASTER RACE 01 September 2017

VIETNAM ZOMBIE HOLOCAUST #4 31 August 2017

GRIFF GRISTLE: THE SIREN’S SONG 28 August 2017

WONDER WOMAN VOL. 3: THE TRUTH 23 August 2017

THINGS YOU SHOULDN’T REMEMBER #1 17 August 2017

SALTIRE: LEGEND ETERNAL #2 01 August 2017

- Entire Category -

Sign up today!
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner