Book Review: DOCTOR WHO - THE COMPLETE GUIDE

PrintE-mail Written by Julian White

Review: Doctor Who – The Complete Guide / Author: Mark Campbell / Publisher: Constable & Robinson / Release Date: August 6th

Doctor Who: The Complete Guide (aka A Brief Guide to Doctor Who: The Complete Series Guide) provides a short survey of each and every Doctor Who storyline up to and including the first Matt Smith series. Usually, this kind of thing can be quite dry, not to mention a minefield of spoilers, but not in this case. Plot synopses are terse and spoiler-free, and Mark Campbell livens things up by furnishing fascinating “observations” (behind the scenes info) and trenchant verdicts along with a rating out of 10.

The heaps of trivia will turn you into an instant Who anorak. For example, Campbell explains the origins of the famous “howlround” title sequence, and describes how in the Horns of Nimon storyline from Series 17, the Nimon actors wore 12-inch platform heels to increase their height. Meanwhile, some of the verdicts and ratings are surprising, with a number of the Sylvester McCoy episodes scoring highly. On the other hand, Campbell doesn't pull his punches when he thinks a particular storyline is below par, and for that reason this book should be enormously helpful to anyone trying to sort the gems of the vintage Who series from the dross.

Amongst the supplementary material, various small screen spin-offs are also covered in the same way, albeit very briefly, and there are useful lists of lost episodes and book tie-ins. If you want to get into the classic early Who stories and you're bewildered by the slew of different DVDs currently available, then this handy volume could be for you what the sonic screwdriver is for the Doctor.


Suggested Articles:
Part of Star Wars’ sense of wonder has always been the minor details behind the galaxy. As often
Test pilot Mike Melvill wrestles with the controls of SpaceShipOne, as its liquid nitrous oxide rock
George A. Romero has long regarded his 1977 film Martin, the story of a shy, alienated young man’s
Launching at this year’s FantasyCon alongside Jez Winship’s Martin is Theatre of Blood, the seco
scroll back to top

Comments  

 
0 #3 Paul Mount 2013-07-01 23:19
Ah, interesting. I was surprised to see that this edition isn't updated as I know you've updated in the past (and I've enjoyed the previous editions). I have a feeling some old editions have been sent out to the shops as the copy in my local FP I looked at last week stopped at season five.
Quote
 
 
0 #2 Mark Campbell 2013-07-01 22:52
It appears as if Julian White may have been sent the wrong edition to review. The new, revised edition I was asked to update by Constable and Robinson was as up-to-date as I could make it, deadlines allowing. It went right up till "The Snowmen". Thanks for your kind words though, Julian.
Quote
 
 
0 #1 Paul Mount 2013-07-01 15:26
"Including the first Matt Smith series" means this really isn't 'the complete guide' but just a lazy rerelease of the volume issued in 2010 and entitled 'the episode guide'. Mark Campbell has issued several of these books in the past and they've always been updated; shame this seems to be just a cheap cash-in for the anniversary year than the chance to brings things a bit more up to date.
Quote
 

Add comment

Security code
Refresh

Sign up today!
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner