Book Review: THE FURTHER ADVENTURES OF SHERLOCK HOLMES - SHERLOCK HOLMES VS DRACULA

PrintE-mail Written by Julian White

Review: The Further Adventures of Sherlock Holmes – Sherlock Holmes vs. Dracula / Author: Loren D. Estleman / Publisher: Titan / Release Date: Out Now

The world's greatest detective pitted against the Prince of Darkness! Sounds like one helluva rumble, yes? So why does this book, dating from 1978 and now reissued by Titan, end up feeling like such a lightweight affair? Well, it's kind of elementary ...

You see, rather than serving up an entirely new Holmes-Dracula tale, Estleman has simply plonked his story down on top of Bram Stoker's. Thus we have Holmes brought in to investigate the case of a schooner mysteriously running aground, sans crew. Then fast-forward to a foggy sojourn on Hampstead Heath, during which he and Watson encounter a vampiric Lucy Westenra. And so on, until, in a change from Stoker's novel, Dracula kidnaps Mrs. Watson (which doesn't deter them one bit, leading you to think that he might have been better off grabbing Mrs. Hudson instead.)

This dovetailing of Holmes' investigation into the original narrative is nimbly done, but feels a bit pointless. It would be different if Estleman offered some subversive new take on these iconic characters, but he's content to pen a straight Victorian/Edwardian pastiche, with Dracula hissing and swirling his cape and Holmes being impossibly patronizing to poor Watson, turfing him unceremoniously into the waters of Whitby harbour at one point and offering him marital advice at another. Still, the tale rattles along like a hackney cab, and, while it might not do much for Dracula fans, it should certainly entertain Holmes addicts.



Suggested Articles:
David Gemmell is easily one of the most influential fantasy authors of the modern era. His book, Leg
At the time of its release in 1984, Neil Jordan’s The Company of Wolves received mixed reviews: it
Imagine that your innocuous-seeming travel business was the cover for an ultra-top secret agency of
In his 2006 obituary to Nigel Kneale, which opens this fascinating new book on the work of one of Br
scroll back to top

Add comment

Security code
Refresh

Sign up today!
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner