Audio Review: DOCTOR WHO - TRIAL OF THE VALEYARD

PrintE-mail Written by Tony Jones

Trial of the Valeyard Review

Review: Trial of the Valeyard (Doctor Who) / Author: Alan Barnes, Mike Maddox / Publisher: Big Finish Productions / Starring: Colin Baker, Michael Jayston, Linda Bellingham / Release Date: Out Now to subscribers (general release, December 2014)

Every December Big Finish release a special single CD story which subscribers to their main range get for free. This year’s tale is Trial of the Valeyard by Alan Barnes and Mike Maddox, and it will not be available on general release until December 2014. Directed by Barnaby Edwards and starring Colin Baker as the Sixth Doctor, this is a reprise in some ways of the 1986 TV series Trial of a Timelord, with Lynda Bellingham returning as the Inquisitor and Michael Jayston as the Valeyard.

Although this story presses lots of fan buttons, a more casual listener will be quickly brought up to speed: all you need to know is that the Doctor was once on trial for his life, prosecuted by the Valeyard, who was later revealed to be the dark side of the Doctor from between his 12th and 13th incarnations. This story is all about the Valeyard now being on trial and the Doctor defending him. There are plenty of amusing moments, great interplay between characters and several twists and turns. The drama is split over three acts and the final of these involves an encounter that will leave any fan pleased with the number of references back to the show’s deepest history.

Despite being primarily a December giveaway, this is a solid story produced to the publisher's normal high standards and is very entertaining. In this anniversary year and with the forthcoming Time of the Doctor addressing the regeneration limit, it is interesting that this story comes very close to giving a definitive view on what is and isn’t possible with Time Lord regeneration and it goes deep into the mythology of the show without closing off any possibilities. The writers need to be congratulated for the care they took with the plotting and indeed everyone should be pleased with their contributions to this release.



Suggested Articles:
In this second half of the two-part finale to the current series of Fourth Doctor adventures, the Do
The latest instalment in Big Finish’s new series of audio adaptations of literary classics publish
With this second set of Prisoner stories, writer (and director) Nick Briggs follows the mix of adapt
It was a risky decision for Big Finish to do the unthinkable and recast one of the Doctors on audio,
scroll back to top

Add comment

Security code
Refresh

Other articles in Audio Reviews

DOCTOR WHO: THE THIEF WHO STOLE TIME 17 September 2017

THE TIME MACHINE 17 September 2017

THE PRISONER VOLUME 2 31 August 2017

THE THIRD DOCTOR ADVENTURES VOL. 3 24 August 2017

THE BLOOD FURNACE 22 August 2017

TORCHWOOD: THE DYING ROOM 22 August 2017

DOCTOR WHO – THE SKIN OF THE SLEEK 22 August 2017

DARK SHADOWS: LOVE LIVES ON 17 August 2017

CLASSIC DOCTORS, NEW MONSTERS VOL. 2 17 August 2017

HAMLET 17 August 2017

- Entire Category -

Sign up today!
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner